Quote of the day

“I find economics increasingly satisfactory, and I think I am rather good at it.”– John Maynard Keynes
Showing posts with label skills. Show all posts
Showing posts with label skills. Show all posts

Tuesday, 8 April 2025

Long but very useful post on human capital and levelling up:

 

Focusing on Human Capital has failed to level up Britain. We should change course.

Tom Forth, .

In late 2021, the Chief Executive of Centre for Cities Andrew Carter interviewed three academics with jobs in East Germany. They spoke about that country’s experience of reunification and the levelling up of the former DDR that followed it. I listened to it at the time and I thought it was good. I must have been tired or in a bad mood back then because I listened to it again recently and now I think it’s brilliant.

The three Germans start by going back to 1990 and describing North England.

Infrastructure built a century ago and barely maintained since the war. Towns reliant on single industries still using century-old technologies. Depopulated cities constrained by continued political dispreference and disempowered by political centralisation.

Just kidding, they were describing East Germany. But it felt a bit too familiar.

Of course, East Germany had it much worse than us here in North England. And while we don’t know how much worse, we can be sure that East Germany upon reunification had a much weaker economy.

Communism is bad.

Communism is really bad and after forty years of trying to make it work, the people of East Germany voted overwhelmingly for parties who promised to give it up quickly. Reunification was not a merger, it was the rapid imposition of West Germany’s economic and political model on the East.

State-owned industries including the housing stock were quickly privatised. Infrastructure was transformed — electrical grids and sewage systems were upgraded, railways were electrified, new train stations were built, metro systems were extended, trams were replaced, and motorways were built from scratch where necessary. Research institutes were improved and added to.

Importantly, West Germany’s model of federalism was imposed. The six states that had been abolished and replaced with central control from East Berlin (and Moscow) under communism were re-established. These New States were given substantial freedom to raise taxes, get those taxes generously topped up by solidarity funds from the rest of the country, and helped to spend much of their money as they felt best.

The results have been astounding.

From well behind in 1990, the economy of the new states overtook North England’s in 2010. By 2016 this was true even ignoring Berlin, whose status as a national capital probably gives it some economic advantages.

From well behind in 1990, East Germany's economy has overtaken North England's.

This has involved hard choices and difficult trade-offs. Deindustrialisation that had taken two decades in North England happened in less than a decade in East Germany. A very similar social pain was experienced even more deeply.

Deindustrialisation which took two or three decades in North England and the Midlands happened in less than a decade in East Germany.

In a dash for growth and modernity, all of Germany’s new states focused their energy on the large cities which had been suppressed under communism. East Germany’s large city economies have all enormously outperformed North England’s. Their success is why East Germany is richer today.

The five largest East German cities have strengthened their economies about twice as quickly as their equivalents in North England since 2001. Their outperformance since 1990 is even greater but there is no good comparable data.

But small cities and towns in East Germany have fallen well behind and shrunk rapidly. The socialist model town of Hoyerswerda today has less than half the population it did in its centrally-planned prime. Unemployment and out-migration have left many of the people who remain there miserable and ignored.

In the 2021 German federal elections over a third of the people in Hoyerswerda’s constituency voted for the far-right Alternative for Deutschland (AfD). The party easily won the seat, just as they had in the previous election. This week they even more strongly backed AfD in the European Elections.

Skills.

Back to the podcast. We’re just about to reach the 30 minute mark. We’ve heard about a hugely successful example of levelling up where regions with a weak economy outperform and close the gap with regions with stronger economies. We’ve heard about huge investment in infrastructure, huge investment in science and technology, and tax raising powers backed up by large fiscal transfers to powerful local units of democratic government with lots of freedom to create and carry out local plans for growth.

No-one has mentioned skills yet. Nor has anyone mentioned human capital, the economics jargon which means more or less the same. This is astonishing.

In a 2023 Spectator podcast with Tyler Cowen, after a day of conference discussions with some of Britain’s top London-based thinkers on economic growth, it takes just three minutes for him to suggest to Kate Andrews that North England’s economic weakness could be due to persistent Human Capital issues. In the UK government’s 2022 levelling up white paper, Human Capital is listed top of the six capitals we need to consider to get levelling up right. Back in 1997 when he was preparing for government Tony Blair famously said that his three priorities were “education, education, education,… because nothing matters more to the future prosperity of the country”.

In over a decade of experience at conferences and roundtables working on levelling up strategy and industrial policy in Britain I’ve found that skills is almost always promoted as the top thing to invest in to achieve economic growth in lagging regions of Britain.

 

No doubt shell-shocked, Andrew Carter intervenes at the half hour point. What about human capital? he asks.

Dr Matthias Brachert at IWH Halle explains that “in the first period there was more investment in physical capital and now we are trying to shift policy in favour of investing in human capital”.

Carter, relieved, says — “we hear this a lot in Britain that one of the ways we’re going to level up is large investment in physical capital whether it’s land or buildings and transport and actually as we all know it’s investment in human capital that makes a material difference over time”.

But we just heard that Germany’s success at levelling up its new states in the East following reunification was based on a focus on physical capital, not human capital. Why do we think it is human capital that makes the material difference when the opposite seems to be the lesson here?

I don’t often hear the focus on physical capital that Andrew reports. Much more often I hear the importance of physical capital talked down, often sneeringly, and the focus shifted to human capital and investment in skills. I don’t agree that it’s investment in human capital that makes the material difference.

Focusing on human capital has failed.

I am often quite a lonely voice in arguing against a focus on human capital. Andrew’s statement is the dominant opinion in the large number of meetings and conferences I’ve attended on regional development, economic growth, and levelling up in Britain, especially in South East England.

And as a result we are a country which spends more on education than our more prosperous neighbours.

The UK has consistently spent more on education as a percentage of GDP than other countries in North Europe who have done better at levelling up their lagging regions. The gap is especially large with Germany.

We achieve a lot with this investment.

According to recent PISA results, our schools outclass France, Germany, the Netherlands, Denmark, and many other countries of Northern Europe. We have accumulated more human capital in terms of graduates than our neighbours too. Far more of our workforce, both young and old, possess a tertiary (university equivalent) education for example.

By many measures of human capital accumulation, the UK, including North England, has outperformed competitor countries whose economies have nevertheless grown more quickly.

These strengths are not just reserved for our prosperous regions. By our best estimates, North England has just as high a graduate population percentage as the Netherlands and a far higher graduate population percentage than Germany. By international rankings North England’s universities are better than the best in those nations.

North England certainly has a much higher intensity of graduates than East Germany. And again, if we trust international rankings, vastly better universities.

And yet it is Denmark, the Netherlands, Germany and the rest of Northern Europe who are economically well ahead of North England and Britain as a whole. And it is East Germany that from a starting position well behind us has caught, overtaken, and is now pulling away economically from North England. They haven’t done this by reindustrialising either, but rather by beating us in a high value services world with a high value service economy.

Why? I’ve long argued it’s because while North England was trying and failing to level up with a human capital approach, those places did things that worked better.

Better transport, spending on research and development, and replacing central planning with local power.

An outsider’s perspective.

I have made myself sound more alone in my pushback against what I see as a British over-emphasis on human capital as the route to levelling up than I am. And Andrew and I agree on this much more than I’m suggesting. I won’t name people who share my opinions in local government and academia, mostly in North England and Scotland, without their permission. But I will name a researcher whose work I hope could mark a turning point in British thinking on levelling up.

In Anna Stansbury’s “Tackling the UK’s regional economic inequality: Binding constraints and avenues for policy intervention” paper in 2023, she and her co-authors argue that British second cities have unusually poor transport infrastructure, enjoy unusually low public spending on science and technology, and are unusually disempowered by their central governments.

This is useful but not groundbreaking. More innovatively, they show in findings since reproduced by the Resolution Foundation that the graduate premium in these cities is falling and is now well below the level in London, suggesting that further increases to graduate levels in the cities will deliver diminishing returns.

Falling graduate premiums in large UK cities outside of London suggests that further increasing human capital in those cities should not be a priority while other barriers to growth persist.

I don’t think it is a coincidence that Anna wrote that paper at MIT, outside of the UK national policy circles that I feel overweigh human capital as a route to levelling up.

If our current approach to levelling up of focusing on human capital isn’t working what should we do instead?

Doing what works.

A good place to start would be to do something similar to what East Germany did. Of course we would do it in our way, I am not a simplistic “copy Germany” person and indeed many other countries in Europe were achieving similar success to East Germany well before it. I think we could do even better in many ways, especially given our significant advantage of proximity London, Paris, and Amsterdam. But we should move in the direction that we have seen work. Instead of education, education, education, we should pick the three priorities that worked. Infrastructure, research, and local power.

We should invest in physical capital, especially in better transport systems, with a strong focus on our big cities. East Germany has twice as many metro stations, eight times as many tram stops, and high speed railway lines — both new and upgraded — connecting its cities. It has nearly completely electrified its mainline railway. It has built new underground railway stations of the kind we have had cancelled.

Meanwhile North England is home to the largest city in Europe without a metro (Manchester), the largest city in Europe without any mass transit system (Leeds), the largest city in Europe except Tirana, the capital of Albania, without a single electric rail service (Sheffield), and probably the largest pair of neighbouring cities in the rich world not connected by a motorway of some form (Sheffield and Manchester).

We should set up lots of research institutes and triple public spending on R&D to fund them. In 2018 UK public spending on R&D in North England was €2.2bn. In East Germany in 2019 it was €8bn. This is not an appeal for reindustrialisation. East Germany beats North England with a service economy, not a manufacturing one. It is an appeal for a more efficient allocation of research funding in Britain.

We should reduce central control and central planning by the UK government and decentralise power to more local levels of government. In Germany, 34% of total tax is raised locally: 25% by states and 9% by local government. This is the same percentage as in the USA. Meanwhile in the UK, all local government combined raises less than 5% of total tax and has correspondingly limited freedom to plan for growth and fund its plans.

We shouldn’t abandon the brilliant work we’ve done as a country on education. There may be some parts of education, especially around further and adult education, where there’s still a lot of work to do. But we should probably be judging how good our plans for levelling up are by how low down the list of priorities education comes. And we should be mindful that our great success on education has delivered poor economic results for much of our country.

Why change course?

Where we have tried this approach, it has worked. Scotland’s economy has rapidly outgrown North England and the Midlands since it voted for and achieved devolution in 1999. It did this by following quite a lot of the East German playbook. We should expect similar outcomes here if we try something similar.

But my feeling is that most of England doesn’t want to level up its North like Germany wanted to level up its East. Not really. Our desires often feel closer to East Germany before reunification.

There, the arguments of Marx and Engels against agglomeration meant that central planning was used to promote towns instead of cities. When Rishi Sunak vetoed the Treasury’s recommendation to place a Northern outpost in Manchester or Leeds and insisted on Darlington instead, he was doing the same.

In the old East Germany, local and state government was replaced with central planning from East Berlin. Where Britain’s levelling up funds are deliberately designed to circumvent existing local governments and deliver money directly to new smaller units such as Towns Boards via competitive bids or micro-managed dispersal of central funds they are doing something very similar, but from London.

Much of our national discussion on the topic of levelling up assumes that North England, and the people of North England, lack some necessary features needed to prosper that East Germany and East Germans have. With a varying mix of solidarity and condescension we are told that we would be better off quietly enjoying decent public services paid for with Southern money as our relative decline is managed.

I reject this evaluation and this vision of the future emotionally. But even for those with cooler heads, there is a problem with continuing on that course that seems increasingly insurmountable; the cost of economic failure in North England and the Midlands is more and more unaffordable.

Upon reunification huge amounts of money started flowing from West Germany to the East. A new solidarity tax was set up to make such flows more visible. The fiscal transfers within Germany at the time were almost certainly far higher than those within the UK.

But by 2010, the success of the East German economy meant that fiscal transfers there had shrunk to be lower than those within the UK. At the time that East Germany’s economy was overtaking North England’s it was receiving about the same inward transfer of money from the rest of the country.

Reunification led to huge transfers of money from West Germany to East Germany but strong economic growth in the East had reduced these to similar levels of fiscal transfer to those within England by 2010. Further economic growth in East Germany since then means that fiscal transfers within Germany are almost certainly lower than within the UK.

Since 2010, East Germany’s economy has closed the gap further on the rest of Germany and its need for fiscal transfers from the West has decreased as a result.

In Britain we have moved in the opposite direction. As places like North England and the Midlands have fallen further behind the rest of the nation’s economy, and especially far behind London’s economy, their needs for fiscal transfers to maintain public services has increased.

Twenty-five years of weak economic growth in the UK outside of London and Scotland has increased fiscal transfers within the UK substantially and left the UK's public services ever more reliant on taxes raised in London.

Without levelling up North England and the Midlands, home to nearly half of all Britons and Europe’s third largest metropolitan area, I doubt that we have a plan to reverse this trend. London’s success will increasingly have to support public spending across the whole country. And while many people in and around power in Britain seem happy to continue flying the economy on only one engine, it is unclear for how much longer that engine can support the ever-increasing fiscal weight.

 

Tuesday, 16 April 2024

Meanwhile apprenticeship numbers are falling

 

UK apprenticeships are on the decline — what went wrong?

The number of people starting workplace training has plunged amid mounting worries about youth employment. Too much of the funding, it is argued, is going to the wrong age groups

ILLUSTRATION BY TONY BELL
The Sunday Times
Share

When Lucy Shepherd turned up to a job interview on an industrial estate on the edge of Crawley, near Gatwick airport, she had more than nerves to worry about.

One of the thousands of 16-year-olds whose GCSE exams were cancelled during the 2020 lockdowns, Shepherd had ended up without any passes after it was left to schools to award grades. Now 20, she admitted that her time at school, in Redhill, Surrey, had not been productive: “I was not the greatest… I was more funny than smart. But I wasn’t badly behaved.”

However, she convinced the interviewer that, despite her poor academic record, she had the drive to work and, in November, she started as an apprentice trade supplier at CCF, the home insulation arm of Travis Perkins. Proudly kitted out in CCF’s all-black uniform, Shepherd said she had been given a second chance in winning a place as an apprentice.

She is one of the lucky ones. Even though politicians have been promising for years to increase the number of school leavers going into apprenticeships, in reality, the amount of schemes on offer has plunged. At a time when Britain is grappling with a rise in the proportion of 16 to 24-year-old “Neets” — those not in education, employment or training — the fall is causing serious concerns.

The number of people starting out on apprenticeships in England has fallen — from 500,000 in 2015 to just 337,000 last year.

The slide is particularly striking since it comes despite a bold government scheme announced by then-chancellor George Osborne in 2015, and launched in 2017, to get “Britain’s great businesses training up the next generation”. Called the apprenticeship levy, it requires big businesses to put 0.5 per cent of their payroll towards the on-the-job training.

So, what has gone wrong?

Lucy Shepherd, 20, is an apprentice at CCF, part of Travis Perkins
Lucy Shepherd, 20, is an apprentice at CCF, part of Travis Perkins
PETER TARRY FOR THE SUNDAY TIMES

For some, the problems start with the perceived vagueness about what problem the levy was meant to solve. Did the government want to use apprenticeships to train those leaving school who were not destined for academic learning? Or was the plan to boost the level of qualifications and skills for older workers through apprenticeships?

“What’s the levy for? Everyone’s got a different answer,” said Matthew Percival, head of work at employers’ body the CBI.

Anyone who thinks the apprenticeship levy should be aimed at training young people just entering the world of work will be disappointed. The number of apprenticeships started by under-19s fell from about 131,000 in 2015-16 to 77,000 in 2022-23. For those aged 19-24, it dropped from 153,000 to 98,000.

For those who argue that the aim of the levy should be to improve the skills of the existing workforce, the data paints a brighter picture: there was a fivefold increase in apprenticeships above A-levels and for those studying for management training qualifications similar to MBAs.

This week, a report by the Association of Colleges, whose members are among those offering the classroom training involved in apprenticeships, will argue that the current system is letting down the young. David Hughes, chief executive, said: “A programme that used to be really important in helping young people get a start in life — particularly those who haven’t done so well at school — has gone in the wrong direction.”

For centuries, apprenticeships have been used to provide the skills that employers have wanted from young people. Even as recently as the 1950s, nearly all teenage boys who did not go into further education became apprentices serving Britain’s manufacturing employers.

A levy is not a new idea either. There was a payroll tax in the 1960s before Margaret Thatcher phased most of those workplace training levies out. It was back on the agenda in the mid-2010s when a paper by the academic Baroness (Alison) Wolf, a professor at King’s College London, highlighted a “broken” apprenticeship system. She found that apprenticeships were operated by central government and produced poor-quality training in lower-level skills. In countries such as France and Germany, Wolf said, the push was for higher-quality, higher-level training.

She suggested a levy that should be paid for by all employers — big and small — and used to create a pool of funding for all businesses to put to use.

Osborne did not adopt the idea entirely, announcing a levy aimed at only the top 2 per cent of employers with a payroll above £3 million. They had to put 0.5 per cent of their wage bill into a pot to train apprentices; if they did not use the funds within two years, the money went to the Treasury. Firms that do not pay the levy contribute 5 per cent towards their training costs.

The apprenticeships would have to last at least a year and be based 80 per cent in the workplace, 20 per cent in the classroom.

According to Tom Richmond at EDSK, the education and skills think tank, the structure of the levy is at the root of the current problem. He argued that it has encouraged the levy-paying employers to use up their contribution by sending existing and senior workers on expensive apprenticeships for management skills, so as to use it up within the two years. Hence the large numbers using the levy for professional development courses.

This appears to be borne out by the data. Level 2 apprenticeships — typically, people leaving school at 16 without formal qualifications and aiming for a specialist skill such as joinery or painting — dropped from about 291,000 apprenticeship starts before the levy to just 76,300 last year. For level 3, an A-level equivalent, the numbers fell from 190,900 to 147,900. Higher apprenticeships — levels 4 to 7, from foundation degree to master’s level — increased from 27,200 to 112,900.

This is “nothing to do with helping inexperienced young people who are trying to get on the career ladder,” Richmond said.

There are many who applaud how higher-level apprenticeships have helped them in their careers and meant that they avoided the average £50,000 debt run up by graduates. At car maker JLR, Suleman Ahmed has just started out on his degree apprenticeship after leaving school with four A*s in physics, maths, further maths and chemistry. He could have gone to Cambridge but decided on the apprenticeship. “When I graduate, I will have four years’ work experience with a top global engineering firm,” said Ahmed, 19.

There are plenty who contend that apprentice schemes should not only be the preserve of the young starter. Lyndsay Casey, 42, started working at recruitment business Adecco when she was 20. Despite leaving school in Yorkshire without maths or English GCSEs, she worked her way up the ranks to become head of operations, and two years ago she did a level 7 apprenticeship — in essence, an MBA.

Lyndsay Casey, 42, at the recruiter Adecco, did a level 7 scheme
Lyndsay Casey, 42, at the recruiter Adecco, did a level 7 scheme
ADECCO

She said the course had made her a better, more productive manager: “It’s changed my approach. I’m more considered, I’ll seek more opinions and support, and I don’t feel I need to do everything on my own.”

But for many employers paying the levy, the view is that the system needs a complete overhaul.

Nathan Kennaugh, managing director at the hi-fi and TV retail chain Richer Sounds, said the system was not “nimble” enough, pointing out that his company wanted to send staff on one-week courses to learn, say, about using Excel — not one-year apprenticeships to acquire such skills. He also said that when he had considered using the levy to pay for a high-level management apprenticeship, he discovered it would be faster and more cost-effective to use a traditional training course.

For the hospitality industry, the strict requirement to spend 80 per cent of the time working and 20 per cent studying is not practical when so much of its work is seasonal in nature. One idea is to adopt a more flexible approach so that the learning could be placed in chunks away from the busy periods. “The rules are quite inflexible,” said Kate Nicholls, chief executive of UKHospitality.

John Roberts, the chief executive of cookers to freezers chain AO World, wants to set up a new working group with other big employers to find a better scheme. “We can take all the learnings from that and incorporate them into the rules of the levy for every other business to benefit from,” he said.

Labour has put changes to the levy on the agenda in the run-up to the election, promising to turn it into a “growth and skills” levy, allowing 50 per cent of the funds to be used for other training. The aim appears to be to encourage firms to reduce spending on higher-level apprenticeships and focus more on younger people.

The government insisted that under-25s were making up “over half of all apprenticeship starts”.

A government spokesman said: “Since 2010 [when the Conservative-Liberal Democrats coalition came to power], almost 5.8 million people have started apprenticeships, which are now more rigorous, provide more training and better reflect the needs of employers.”

While some employers detest the levy and see it as little more than a tax, others have embraced it. Defence giant BAE Systems has a vast college site on the edge of Preston where it trains apprentices on its fighter jet programmes, and has another in Cumbria for submarines. It has bolstered its number of apprentices from 567 in the year the levy started to a record 1,417 this year.

Back in Crawley, Shepherd reflected on how her apprenticeship is boosting her career hopes and self-confidence after she left school without qualifications. “I can see what it looks like on paper, but I’ve got a brain up there,” she said. In six months, she should have a piece of paper with her level 2 apprenticeship — and is already considering what qualification she will start next.

Tuesday, 26 September 2023

More from the esteemed Sam Dimitriu

 Please read right to the end - a little snippet that encapsulates it all: