Quote of the day

“I find economics increasingly satisfactory, and I think I am rather good at it.”– John Maynard Keynes
Showing posts with label enterprise. Show all posts
Showing posts with label enterprise. Show all posts

Sunday, 9 July 2023

Reasons to be Cheerful (Part 3)

 Not many will get the cultural reference in the title, but this is a good piece on growth in the UK tech sector and how it is funded:



Big investors are taking advantage of tax breaks to establish a UK Silicon Valley. By Chris Stokel-Walker

The Sunday Times
Share
Save

You can’t move in Covent Garden and Fitzrovia for American tourists some days, but not all the US accents heard in bars and restaurants around the tourist traps belong to travellers. The US’s biggest tech firms and investors are increasingly calling London their home — and particularly those two enclaves.

Three weeks ago Andreessen Horowitz, one of the largest Silicon Valley venture capital firms, announced it was setting up its first office outside the US in London later this year, led by veteran investor Sriram Krishnan, who will be moving over in a couple of months.

“[Andreessen Horowitz] doing more deals here will certainly attract more international attention to UK start-ups, because the tech world pays close attention to what [it] does,” said Martin Bryant, founder of the London tech newsletter PreSeed Now. Boosting Britain’s brand among the technorati, he added, was a boon in a post-Brexit world.

But it was just the beginning. Two weeks later, it was the turn of ChatGPT creator OpenAI to announce it was opening its first international office in London — thanks to Britain’s “rich culture and exceptional talent pool” — which beat Warsaw and Paris to that prize in a rare fillip for Rishi Sunak. OpenAI joins another UK-based AI company, Stability AI, led by Emad Mostaque.

It’s partly the political environment that attracts tech businesses to London — Sunak has set up a welcoming regime of tax breaks including seed enterprise investment schemes and 50 per cent tax relief on investments up to £200,000 a year, as well as benefits for high-value businesses in tech. He has also signalled his support through stunts such as replacing the “10” on the front door of 10 Downing Street with binary code that read “LTW” for London Tech Week in mid-June. Tech is an interest that stems from Sunak’s time studying for an MBA at Stanford University in California; his wife, a fellow classmate, wasn’t the only love he acquired in the US.

Another benefit of the UK is that it doesn’t require employers to pay so-called “social charges” in addition to income tax, making Britain more attractive than France. In addition, England’s capital city has been an IT destination for some time — “[it] continues to lead the tech sector in Europe, and the interest of US venture capital firms and big tech companies in having an office here underlines that,” said Davor Hebel, managing partner at VC firm Eight Roads Ventures Europe. Nevertheless, London has still been able to build further momentum recently.

“The European [venture] market has posted better returns than the US in recent years and is poised for growth, and London is central to that, which is why US firms moving here is not surprising,” said Manjari Chandran-Ramesh, a partner at Amadeus Capital Partners, another VC firm. “To scale, more capital and wider networks are always required, so I feel this will be positive.”

Sarah Cannon, known for backing Slack, has been instrumental in attracting US investors to LondonSarah Cannon, known for backing Slack, has been instrumental in attracting US investors to London
Sarah Cannon, known for backing Slack, has been instrumental in attracting US investors to London

“London has become a hub for US venture capital investment,” added Lloyd Price, chief executive of Hive Health, a London-based cybersecurity firm. In 2021, American VCs invested £10.6 billion in London start-ups — more than any other year on record. “This trend is likely to continue in the years to come, as US VCs look to London as a source of investment opportunities,” said Price.

Sarah Cannon of investment manager Coatue Management, who backed Slack, and Luciana Lixandru of VC firm Sequoia Capital, who helped the grocery-delivery app Getir to win investment, are two transatlantic transplants to have played a part in setting up UK sites for investors based in America. London is an attractive place for US investments because of its strong tech network, which includes the likes of Deliveroo, Revolut and Wise. “These companies have created a vibrant ecosystem that attracts talent and investment from around the world,” said Price.

But the valuations of the companies that London is producing are generally lower than in the US. In part, that is due to the smaller size of the British tech market, and the different regulatory environment. “US VCs can get more bang for their buck by investing in London start-ups,” said Price. The City is also a useful gateway to the European market; a blockbuster €105 million (£90 million) funding round in June for the French artificial-intelligence start-up Mistral was led by Lightspeed Ventures, which has its European headquarters just outside Covent Garden. “By setting up an office in London, American VCs can gain access to this market and identify potential investment opportunities,” said Price.

The open regulatory environment in the UK is also conducive to growing a start-up, according to Price, which means there are plenty of opportunities to invest in firms and help them succeed.

“With investors who have access to global insights and talent, a supportive political environment and deep pools of capital on their doorstep, I see the UK tech sector only gaining in stature,” said Chris Bischoff, managing director for Europe and the US at General Catalyst, a private equity firm.

For decades, London faced criticism that it was a great city in which to grow a company, but not a fantastic place to achieve financial returns. Now, it is. High-profile floats and sales of companies based in London have helped to convince investors that they can get returns on their cash. The £8 billion listing of fintech start-up Wise on the London Stock Exchange in 2021 helped investors realise the potential of the UK, even if other companies, such as chipmaker Arm, have chosen to list in the US instead.

Data from the capital’s business development agency, London & Partners, shows that London-based start-up companies raised $22.4 billion from VC firms in 2022, up 800 per cent from 2014.

Much of that cash is coming from US-based funds that used to focus on Silicon Valley. It all means that more Americans — and more American tech figures — are coming over to the UK. They are behind the purchases of more prime properties in central London in the past 12 months than any other nationality, according to estate agency Knight Frank.

Those incomers include former deputy prime minister Nick Clegg, now an executive at Meta, the parent company of Facebook and Instagram, who recently returned to the UK. Clegg was born in the sleepy Buckinghamshire village of Chalfont St Giles, but headed stateside in 2018 after leaving politics.

Heading in the other direction across the Atlantic, perhaps to help launch the newly released Threads app, is Instagram chief Adam Mosseri, who decamped to London several years ago.

Some big American tech players, including Bessemer Ventures’ Alex Ferrara, are now joking on LinkedIn that their children have assimilated so well that they are picking up British accents. It’s all welcome news for London’s tech sector — whose movers and shakers may soon speak with a Californian lilt.

Thursday, 8 December 2022

Our "shockingly high" tax regime

 Matthew Lynn

Britain’s shockingly high tax burden

The higher rate was once for fat cats. Now, more and more of us end up paying it. That will stifle growth

You need to have been following Budget speeches for a long time to remember when the 40% top rate of tax was introduced.  It made its debut on 15 March 1988, when Margaret Thatcher’s chancellor Nigel Lawson embarked on a far-reaching reform of the tax system. The basic rate of tax was reduced from 27% to 25%, corporation and inheritance taxes were reformed and, most radically, not to say controversially, the top rate was sliced from 60% to just 40%. It was designed to be a top rate of tax that would only be paid by a small fraction of the workforce and even then would not take such a high share of their income as to deter them from working. By 1990, only  1.7 million people were paying the 40% rate. By the time Tony Blair became prime minister that total had risen to 2.1 million and by 2010 it was 3.3 million. 

Ever since then, however, the numbers have started to explode. By 2019 the total was up to 4.3 million, and in the current tax year it will be up to six million. Simply freezing the thresholds, as Rishi Sunak did as chancellor, combined with inflation running at more than 10% a year, has pushed more and more people into the top bracket. Now, Sunak’s chancellor, Jeremy Hunt, has frozen the thresholds all over again, a move that will take at least another two million people into the bracket by 2028, making a total of eight million, or more then five times the number when it was introduced. 

ADD IN THE “GRADUATE TAX”

The reality is even worse than it sounds. The workforce is shrinking rapidly – more than a million people have left it since the pandemic. It is likely that the bulk of those are concentrated at the lower end of the wage scale, for the simple reason that anyone earning a big salary is a lot more likely to be doing a job they enjoy and that they find rewarding. As more and more low earners leave the workforce, discouraged by poor earnings and higher taxes, the percentage of top-rate payers in the overall workforce will inevitably rise. 

And, as columnists at Bloomberg argued last week, we should also take into account student-loan repayments, which are effectively a graduate tax. Ever since fees went up to £9,000 a year at the start of the last decade, most students are now emerging with £50,000 of debt, or often more. With the “graduate tax” kicking in at 9% even on a fairly modest income of £30,000 a year, that has to be added in to get a sense of what the marginal tax rate actually is. Add in national insurance and the loan repayment, and anyone on that income with a degree will actually be paying 40% tax long before they reach the actual threshold for the higher rate (and they will be paying a shocking 70% at higher incomes, but that is a different story). In other words, far more people are paying the higher rate than the official figures suggest, and the numbers will be rising all the time as more and more graduates with higher debts enter the labour market. 

THE NEW STANDARD RATE

Add it all up and up to half of the workforce of 31 million and perhaps more could end up paying the top rate. In reality, 40% will not be a top rate anymore. It won’t even be a higher rate. It will be the new standard rate. On current trends, within a few years there will be a 20% rate for low earners, a standard 40% rate for most of us, and a  top 45% rate (although in reality probably  a 50% rate by then) for the wealthy. Without any real discussion, and without anyone pausing to ask whether that is healthy for the economy, that is where we are inevitably heading. 

This is scandalous. A 40% standard rate of income tax is ridiculously high, especially when people are paying 20% VAT on anything they buy, on top of fuel duty, stamp duty, inheritance tax, and all the other levies the state imposes. As Nigel Lawson realised, the key to unlocking greater enterprise and improving incentives is to leave more money in people’s pockets. A rate that takes almost half a person’s income will for most be a crushing burden that will squeeze the life out of the economy.

Monday, 28 June 2021

A bit of supply-side

 

A revamped New Enterprise Allowance would do wonders for business creation

By  

It is not often you find a Thatcherite policy that is just as likely to be celebrated in The Guardian or the RSA, as it is by The Daily Telegraph. The Enterprise Allowance Scheme (EAS) was a rare exception.

The idea is simple: pay the unemployed to start a business. The results were impressive. Success stories included Alan McGee’s Creation Records and Julian Dunkerton’s SuperDry clothing brand. It also helped launch the careers of Young British Artists (YBAs) such as Jeremy Deller and Tracey Emin.

It was also excellent value for money. One analysis by the World Bank estimated that it cost under £5,000 (adjusted for inflation) per job created. This is about as good as it gets for labour market policy. By contrast, some recent schemes have cost as much as 40 times more per job created. 

Yet its successor scheme, the New Enterprise Allowance (NEA), falls short in a number of key ways. At its peak, more than 100,000 were enrolled on the Enterprise Allowance Scheme at one time. By contrast, there have only been slightly more starts on the NEA over the past decade.

What explains the relative failure? A key problem is the level of support on offer. The EAS offered recipients £40 a week in the 80s, which is slightly more than what they could get from Job Seekers Allowance (JSA). The NEA is a fair bit stingier: you can claim up to £1,274 over six months, roughly 25% less than what you would have got on JSA.

The support does not last for long either. At the end of six months, you are effectively on your own. This wasn’t the case for the original EAS, where support lasted for a year.

There’s a further complication too. Under Universal Credit, benefits are gradually tapered away, which can create further uncertainty for the self-employed as to what they will have at the end of the month.

A scheme closer to the original EAS could have a powerful impact in the parts of the UK where poverty and deprivation are most stubborn to shift. We recently worked with Sage and Portland to poll over a thousand SMEs and people open to the idea of starting a business in some of the most deprived parts of London and Newcastle.

The polling revealed that starting a business is seen as a route to a better life for many people who are currently stuck in low-paid work. Entrepreneurship isn’t just a pipe dream either. Almost half the people we spoke to had clear business ideas. However, these ideas were not translating into new business creation because of two key barriers: finance and confidence.

Sometimes the problems were a matter of perception. The people we polled thought starting a business would cost £12,000. By contrast, the SME owners we spoke reckoned it only cost them £5,000. Most people would still fall short, but the gap isn’t insurmountable.

To make up the shortfall, external finance will be necessary. But the idea of taking out a loan, especially in a year where most have seen their income fall and businesses close, seems daunting to most.

In theory, the NEA should be perfect for them, but it is unlikely that just over £1,000 over six months is sufficient. If we were to expand the NEA to £100 a week over 12 months, as Policy Exchange have advocated, it would enable every recipient to find that £5,000 to cover startup costs.

There is one aspect of the NEA that is worth keeping. Under the current system support is frontloaded. After all, you are most likely to need support in your first few weeks before you’ve made that crucial first sale.

An expanded NEA should keep that aspect but increase flexibility. On the approval of a business mentor, you should be able to access up to 50% of your last six months worth of entitlement upfront.

We should also look at expanding eligibility. The scheme is only available to people receiving benefits. As a result, we might be missing out on supporting people who have developed side-hustles while on furlough. Similarly, those under 23 earning less than the National Living Wage could also benefit from support to start a business. Indeed, many of the Enterprise Allowance Scheme’s biggest successes were people who joined the scheme in their early twenties.

It wouldn’t be a silver bullet – we still need better support in terms of mentoring and entrepreneurship education up and down the curriculum. But it could help us take advantage of the massive opportunity to support the creation of new businesses in the parts of the UK where they are most needed.

Thursday, 8 June 2017

2 topics - enterprise zones and green belt

Two points from a bigger article (linked) suggesting 5 things that could help U.K. Grow. The first section, Growth Flashpoints, will give you material to use on red tape/deregulation, ideas for structural change & government assistance for that, future jobs growth. The second section on building homes may still come into Paper 3, but may also work in Paper 2, as a suggestion for reducing labour immobility/helping structural/regional unemployment, and relieving housing pressure in the South East:


1 GROWTH FLASHPOINTS

The UK needs more growth, and should secure its place in the world of the future by taking steps now to attract high tech start-ups. These will ultimately create the jobs that will keep our own high-skills people in the country and will attract high skills people from overseas.

Business entrepreneurs claim that they find regulation the biggest bugbear. Instead of developing and expanding their businesses they have to spend hours ling compliance documents and meeting the minutiae of rules imposed by both national and central government. When they employ people they complain about the amount of time and effort taken up by PAYE tax returns and National Insurance. Their premises have to meet exacting standards, and it is claimed that firms such as Apple could never have started up in the UK because they would not have been allowed to operate from a garage.

In an ideal world we would not burden our start-up businesses with the costs of regulatory compliance, but in this less than ideal world we could have small pockets where start-ups could develop unhindered. The government should learn from the successes and failures of its Enterprise Zones project from the early 1980s. The idea was bold, but its execution was limited because the civil service put too many curbs upon the new zones. Its greatest success was in London’s Docklands, where skyscrapers could be built only because it was designated as an Enterprise Zone.

The government should announce a nationwide competition to have places designated as Growth Flashpoints. Syndicates of business, trade unions and local government should put together bids to be one of the chosen sites, listing in their bids the facilities and terms they were prepared to o er high-tech start-ups establishing with the flashpoints, including buildings that would be available and transport links. They could be about one square mile in area, with perhaps four or five to be chosen across the nation.

The rules would be simple. For their first five years new high-tech start-ups within the flashpoints would pay no taxes, local or national. They would be exempt from regulations that covered premises, employment, health and safety, or the need to file compliance documents. All those working within the flashpoints would be classfied as self-employed, with employers therefore not required to o er non-wage benefits such as holiday or sick pay.

The bids put in by local areas wishing to be one of the designated flashpoints would be adjudicated by a panel of people from high tech industries, not by ministers or civil servants. And applications by would-be start-ups to set up within a flashpoint would be approved or rejected by similar panels drawn from the technology sector. 

2 CREATING LIVING SPACE

The UK’s housing shortage is not caused by lack of finance to build houses, or by lack of labour or materials. It is caused by a lack of suitable land that people are allowed to build on. It is exacerbated by some of the conditions that local authorities impose by tacking on to planning permission such things as the necessity of including a proportion of “social housing.”

It is the Green Belt created by the 1947 Town and Country Planning Act and revised since which prevents towns and cities expanding outwards as their population increases. Political pressures from environmentalist organizations and wealthy home-owners who have homes within it or overlooking it have conspired to prevent development. 

Some towns and cities make the problem worse by putting height restrictions on buildings erected within them, effectively meaning that residences cannot expand outward or upward, so people are having to buy beyond the green belt and commute through it to work in the city.

People have recently softened their opposition to any kind of green belt development, and this creates an opportunity for a novel approach to be tried. Government should decide to slice a mile off the inner circumference of the green belt, and add a mile to its outer circumference. Verdant land within that inner mile would be preserved, meaning that meadows, woods and genuinely green land would be left untouched. But damaged land such as disused buildings, gravel pits and the like, would be available for development,
as would prime agricultural farmland, itself not particularly green.

The mile added to the outer circumference would not apply to buildings already there, and could be added in such a way as to create more verdant, genuinely green land. This would result in a net gain of green land, in that the inner circumference of the green belt is smaller than the outer one.

Environmentalists could draw consolation from the net gain of green, while the strip of land around the inner circumference would allow a million more new homes to be built where they are needed, in towns and cities where people want to live and work.

Families presently living in the green belt could console themselves with the thought that at least their children would have somewhere to live in the future. The building of a million new homes on the edge of the green belt would put downward pressure on the prices of existing homes, making it easier for young people to become home-owners. It would break the cycle of expectation in the UK that house prices must inevitably rise, and that a home is an investment rather than a place to live, and an investment that will yield greater returns than practically any other. 

When this is no longer true, people will seek other assets in which to invest, creating opportunities for business expansion and job creation. The actual construction of a million new homes would put some strain on the supply of materials such as bricks and timber, but output could be stepped up to meet the new
demand. And the building, done over the course of several years, would itself give a massive boost to employment within the industry, creating well-paid jobs and opportunities for skilled craftsmen. The ultimate bottom line, however, is that many more people, especially young people, would gain the opportunity to become home-owners.