Quote of the day

“I find economics increasingly satisfactory, and I think I am rather good at it.”– John Maynard Keynes
Showing posts with label laffer curve. Show all posts
Showing posts with label laffer curve. Show all posts

Thursday, 27 February 2025

Nice example of the Laffer Curve:

 

Reeves’s tax raid is firing up Britain’s hidden economy

Cash economy may be on rise as self-employed seek to dodge Chancellor’s higher taxes

Rachel Reeves's tax demands may have inadvertently boosted the cash economy
Rachel Reeves’s tax demands may have inadvertently boosted the cash economy Credit: Simon Dawson / No 10 Downing Street

Rachel Reeves should beware: the black, or hidden, economy is once more on the rise, and it may have something to do with the Chancellor’s own tax demands.

There’s a Thai restaurant near where I live where a sign prominently displayed in the window reads “Cash only, no credit or debit cards”.

At first blush, this would seem curiously counter to the wider trend of restaurants and cafes refusing to accept cash. Notes and coins are expensive to process relative to digital payments, and are also acutely vulnerable to the plague of petty crime.

Dig a little deeper, however, and you find that the cash economy may once more be strongly on the rise.

Hard evidence for this contention is admittedly mixed, even if anecdotally it might seem strong. Fewer people carry cash – but especially for casual work, many more are demanding it.

The Bank of England insists that the amount of physical cash issued follows no particular formula, but in any one year is only an estimate of likely demand.

This might suggest little or no increase in the size of the cash economy. None the less, both the number and value of bank notes in circulation have risen considerably over time despite the explosive growth in digital payments for day-to-day purchases.

Between 2005 and 2017, the value of banknotes in circulation doubled, outstripping the growth in the economy by some margin. Even adjusting for rising economic activity and price levels, notes in circulation have been trending upwards ever since the early 1990s.

The big jump, however, was during the pandemic, when demand for physical cash rose strongly even as economic activity collapsed and scare stories proliferated that the use of bank notes was a key cause of viral infection.

The Bank of England has explained this apparent paradox by pointing to the growing attractions of cash as a store of value at a time of low inflation and rock-bottom interest rates.

But my guess is that there is more to it than that.

Relatively recent survey evidence by HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) suggested that 8.8pc of UK adults participated in the “hidden” economy, in 2022, well up on the 4.9pc of the previous estimate in 2015 to 2016.

A further 4.8pc of the population were identified as being “possibly involved” in the hidden economy, up from 0.6pc in 2015 to 2016.

Off-the-books use of cash as a means of payment is not solely determined by the amount of cash in circulation either. It’s the velocity of money, rather than its quantity, which determines its economic value. A single £10 note might, for instance, be exchanged multiple times in a day.

More or less everyone will have had some experience of the black economy even if they haven’t themselves participated in it.

Cash is king, many tradesmen will say given the choice between cash and a bank transfer or credit card payment. Generally, the price is lower for cash.

Many of these payments will not be wholly declared for tax purposes. It’s only on very large transactions that cash tends to become impractical and/or hard to hide from the taxman.

Two points are worth making here. One is that if the hidden economy is indeed breaking new ground, it means that the economy as a whole is stronger than the official data suggests.

Rather more worrying for the Government, it also means that a growing proportion of economic activity is escaping the tax net. We may already be seeing this played out in real time as a result of measures in Reeves’s Budget to significantly raise the tax burden.

Tax revenues in January, traditionally a buoyant month because of the deadline for self-assessment, fell significantly short of Office for Budget Responsibility expectations.

Reeves may already be hitting the “Laffer curve” of diminishing returns, particularly among smaller enterprises and the self-employed, whereby higher taxes lead to growing avoidance and evasion.

With personal tax thresholds now frozen until 2027 to 2028, the trend is likely only to get worse.

Self-employed and part-time workers may be choosing to take a greater proportion of what they earn in the form of under-the-counter cash payments. With rising taxes, small and occasional cash earnings are particularly vulnerable to non disclosure.

Nor is it just higher taxes pushing people into the hidden economy. Pressure on disposable incomes from the cost of living crisis further increases the incentives to demand tax-free cash payment for goods and services.

A House of Commons public accounts committee report back in 2020 found that the Bank of England did not “appear to have a convincing reason for why the demand for notes keeps increasing” or any real understanding of where approximately £50bn of issued sterling notes are, or what they are being used for.

Worry not, says HMRC. The so-called “tax gap” – the difference between what HMRC thinks should be paid in tax and what is actually being paid – has been in steady decline for years. At the last estimate, it stood at 4.8pc, or £39.8bn, of what should have been collected.

This would not suggest a growing black economy. Maybe, but given what I see happening all around me, and the manifestly growing incentives for tax-dodging, I remain to be convinced.

As on so much else, we’re plunging back to the “fallen off the back of a lorry” economy of the 1970s and the early 1980s, where tax avoidance and evasion was the name of the game.

This was the unofficial economy of Arthur Daley and Only Fools and Horses. If you tax too much, don’t be surprised when you hit a brick wall of refusal to pay.

Friday, 24 January 2025

UK's (and Europe's) problems in a nutshell

 Anything that doesn't address the core is just tinkering:


My monologue on today’s The Times at One 1pm, live from New York: It’s only the start of the third full day of the new Trump administration but already we can see what an economic and business threat it poses to an ailing Europe, including the UK.  And it’s about much more than tariffs. Trump aims to consolidate America’s economic supremacy with lower taxes, cheaper energy, much less regulation.  It’s worth noting that taxes in Europe and the UK are already much higher than in America, energy is much more expensive and business far more highly regulated. That explains why America has come out of the pandemic downturn far more robustly than Europe.  Trump now wants to go faster on all three fronts, so that America pulls even further ahead of Europe than it already is.  As Europe continues to stagnate, America is poised to grow more. Multi-billion dollar investments in AI and other cutting edge technologies are being announced, reinforcing America’s clear technological lead.  It’s often thought high-tech business doesn’t consume as much power as the old heavy industries. You couldn’t be more wrong.  Data centres are fierce consumers of electricity, which is why Trump wants even cheaper energy — and why Europe and the UK, which has the highest electricity costs in the world, are struggling to attract these data centres.  Heavy industry in Europe and the UK is still being hollowed out. Not enough new stuff is replacing it.  In the UK alone chemical production is down 38% in just the past three years, cement production down 40%, electrical equipment down 50%. Either they close down because energy costs mean they can’t compete or they flee across the Atlantic, where energy costs are far cheaper.  It’s happening all across Europe.  Yet nobody in Europe is doing anything about it.  Far from cutting red tape, Brussels boasts, absurdly, that the EU is a regulatory superpower. Good luck with getting rich on that.  Far from cutting taxes, almost everywhere in Europe they are being increased, even though they’re already at record levels.  And far from reducing energy prices they continue to rise as Europe puts the huge cost of going for green energy generation onto everybody’s fuel bills.  It’s a hat trick of self-harm which Trump has spotted and intends to exploit.  In Britain Keir Starmer manfully struggles against all the legal constraints on growth and development, many exploited by his legal friends who’ve grown rich on lawfare.  He’s for the builders not the blockers, he claims. Which is good news. But I’d put my money on the blockers winning.  In Davos Rachel Reeves says she’ll look again at the tax regime for non-doms now that 11,000 millionaires and multi-millionaires left Britain in the past year alone to escape her high taxes. I suspect it’s too late to woo them back.  The punk left will say good riddance to them. They don't realise it’s Britain’s tax base walking out the door. Contrary to populist belief, our revenue base is hugely dependent on high earners. The top 1% of earners account for 30% of income tax revenues. The top 0.1% pay over 10% of income tax revenues.  If they go, everybody else will have to pay more tax.  Few in Britain realise this which is why wealth-destroying policies are so popular. It’s not a mistake made here in America, which is prepared to welcome companies escaping Europe’s anti-business climate and the high-earning, tax paying wealth creators that come with them.  By the end of this decade US business will likely be more dominant than ever. And Europe, Britain included, even more of a backwater. For the moment at least, there is nothing on the horizon to change that gloomy prognosis.

Sunday, 19 January 2025

Laffer Curve

 There must be a new rule that says when an article ends with a quote from the Treasury, the spokesperson knows they are defending the indefensible:

Labour’s tax plans trigger exodus of millionaires from UK

Since the general election was called one dollar millionaire has left Britain every 45 minutes
a woman holding a red briefcase that says ' chancellor of the exchequer ' on it
Rachel Reeves is facing calls to reverse the Treasury’s crackdown on non-domiciled residents
JUSTIN TALLIS/AFP/GETTY IMAGES

A record number of millionaires have left Britain since Sir Keir Starmer came to power and there is growing concern that Labour’s tax plans are exiling international investors and damaging the economy.

The Treasury is facing calls to reverse its crackdown on non-domiciled residents as the scale of the exodus becomes clear.

Tax advisers also report that growing numbers of British entrepreneurs are prepared to leave the country after the tax rises announced in the autumn budget.

In total Britain lost a net 10,800 millionaires to migration last year, a 157 per cent increase on 2023, meaning it lost more wealthy residents than any other country except China. The actual number that moved out is even higher because the net figure also takes into account the millionaires who arrived in the UK.

The outflow, mainly to other European countries such as Italy and Switzerland, as well as the United Arab Emirates, was especially large among the UK’s richest residents. Some 78 centi-millionaires and 12 billionaires left the country last year.

The figures were compiled by New World Wealth, the global analytics firm, and investment migration advisors Henley & Partners, which looked at high net-worth individuals with liquid assets of more than $1 million (£821,500). They show that the exodus accelerated after the general election was called. Since that moment one dollar millionaire has left Britain every 45 minutes.

Aerial view of the Abu Dhabi skyline.
Most UK-based non-doms have moved to Switzerland, Italy and, above, the United Arab Emirates
EXTREME PHOTOGRAPHER/GETTY IMAGES

In 2023, HM Revenue & Customs said there were 74,000 non-doms in the UK, and 37,800 of them who have lived in the UK for at least seven years paid a £30,000 annual fee to keep their offshore income and gains sheltered from the taxman.

However, from April, Labour will abolish this centuries-old regime, replacing it with a much less generous residence-based system that will also subject current non-doms’ overseas assets to UK inheritance tax (IHT) for the first time.

• The jewellers and estate agents hit by wealthy quitting Britain

A survey of more than 700 non-doms or their tax advisers by Oxford Economics found that nearly two thirds are planning to leave the UK or considering doing so because of the changes. Most said the principal motivation was the introduction of IHT on their world wide assets, while many other jurisdictions do not levy the tax at all or having more generous reliefs.

Charlie Mullins in Malaga, Spain.
Charlie Mullins, the founder of Pimlico Plumbers, has moved to Spain

The Office for Budgetary Responsibility (OBR) estimates that between 12 and 25 per cent of non-doms will go. If a quarter do leave it could have a significant impact on the economy but also indirectly tax revenues and philanthropy.

The survey found that each non-dom paid an average of £800,000 of VAT in the last tax year, and £890,000 in stamp duty over the previous five years. They have also invested an average of £118 million in the UK since arriving and given an average of £5.9 million to good causes.

‘Monumental self-harm’

The Treasury predicts that Labour’s plan to end the non-dom regime will raise £2.5 billion a year over the next five years. But Oxford Economics says the plans will in fact cost the ­exchequer nearly £1 billion a year because so many non-doms will leave — and that is before the ­impact of lower VAT receipts and other taxes is included.

David Hawkins, of Foreign Investors for Britain, a group representing non-doms, described the government’s policy as “a monumental act of national self-harm”.

He said: “It appears that decisions have been made not based on the evidence but based on ideology. It’s a real worry because more and more people are leaving. And it’s businesses, jobs, investment, spending into the economy and tax take and philanthropy that are hit.”

The group is now working with the Institute of Directors and the British Chambers of Commerce to persuade ministers of the merits of designing “an internationally competitive offer” to overseas entrepreneurs.

Growing numbers of British entrepreneurs are looking at moving abroad. Henley & Partners says it handled a record number of applications from Britons seeking alternative citizenship and overseas residency rights last year. It said demand was up 57 per cent on 2023 and a “staggering” 580 percentage points higher than five years ago.

Stuart Wakeling, Managing Partner at Henley & Partners UK, believes there are a multitude of factors influencing entrepreneurs to leave, such as the bad weather and fears over crime, but that tax remained the biggest motivation.

Uma Thurman and Christian Angermayer at the Time100 Gala.
Christian Angermayer, the German technology entrepreneur, left Britain last year for Switzerland
ANGELA WEISS/AFP/GETTY IMAGES

“Wealthy Britons are consistently telling us that they are becoming more and more disassociated with the country of their birth,” Ferrigno said. “They are realising that although a relocation brings about a significant change and upheaval to their lives, it is a change worth making. The wealthy are also becoming more and more aware that having a plan B, or additional residence or citizenship, is vital in an ever-changing world. Having all your eggs in one basket is risky and sometimes the grass can ultimately be greener elsewhere.”

Other firms have also noted the trend. Rachel De Souza, a private client tax partner at the accountancy firm RSM UK, said the “tables had turned” since October, with demand for relocation advice being driven by non-doms before the budget but also by British entrepreneurs afterwards.

She said: “In virtually all cases, these entrepreneurs are citing the budget announcements as the reason for seeking to move.”

Charlie Mullins, the founder of Pimlico Plumbing, is one of the entrepreneurs who has already left, having recently moved to Spain.

He said: “Britain is in trouble. I’m not going to blame Labour completely, the Tories also lost the plot, but Labour have made it worse. They’ve raised taxes, and added new employment laws like getting a contract from day one. It makes it hard to run a business.”

Other high profile business names have already left or are leaving, including Asif Aziz, the British real-estate investor, who has relocated to Abu Dhabi, and Christian Angermayer, the German technology entrepreneur who quit Britain last year for Switzerland.

Alan Howard, the British hedge fund billionaire, is also reported to be exploring a move to Geneva while Nassef Sawiris, the owner of Aston Villa, is thinking of relocating to the Middle East.

Portrait of Aron Landy, CEO of Brevan Howard.
Alan Howard
HOLLIE ADAMS/BLOOMBERG/GETTY IMAGES

The Adam Smith Institute estimates that by 2035, the non-dom reforms will make the economy £1.3 billion smaller than it would otherwise have been, which could lead to over 23,000 job losses by 2030.

Foreign Investors for Britain wants the Treasury to introduce a tiered tax regime that would charge non-doms a fixed fee depending on their wealth, starting at £200,000 a year for those with assets under £100 million, rising to £2 million a year for those with wealth above £500 million.

Oxford Economics believes this system would actually raise tax revenue for the Treasury.

Leslie Macleod Miller, the chief executive of Foreign Investors for Britain, described a tiered tax regime as a “compromise solution” that would “maintain the UK’s attractiveness to international investors while ensuring fair contributions to the public purse”.

“It’s not too late for the government to work with us on it,” he said.

In a statement, the Treasury said: “We are committed to tax reforms that are progressive and underpinned by fairness. It is right that those who can afford to, contribute their fair share to fix the foundations to provide stability and fund public services to drive growth.”